Introduction
In a significant twist of fate during the 1959-60 NHL season, the New York Rangers found themselves on the wrong side of a trade that never officially went through, a decision that still sparks discussion among fans and historians.
The Controversial Trade
At the heart of this controversial transaction was legendary defenseman Bill Gadsby and winger Eddie Shack, who were set to be traded to the Toronto Maple Leafs in exchange for storied defenseman Red Kelly and forward Billy McNeill. The agreement, brokered by Rangers General Manager Muzz Patrick on February 5, 1960, seemed beneficial for both teams initially, especially with Gadsby and Kelly later being inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame while Shack and McNeill proved to be solid second-line players.
The Fallout
However, the deal fell apart when Kelly opted to retire instead of joining the Rangers, a decision that was ultimately influenced by his desire to sidestep playing for a struggling New York team. According to Associated Press reporter Shelly Sakowitz, Kelly’s retirement was merely a ruse; shortly after, he received an enticing offer from Toronto, leading him to accept that deal.
Impact on Players and Teams
Under the coaching of Punch Imlach, Kelly transitioned to a center position and became pivotal in the Leafs’ success, helping the franchise secure four Stanley Cups within a six-year span.
Conclusion
NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman, in stark contrast to the past, would never allow such a chaotic trade scenario today. Ultimately, the original trade was voided, and Gadsby continued his professional journey, playing a remarkable 20 years in the league but ironically never winning a Stanley Cup himself. The incomplete trade serves as a reminder of the unpredictability of sports deals and the unforeseen consequences they can have on players’ careers.
