Casemiro’s Tumultuous Journey at Manchester United
The trajectory of Casemiro’s career at Manchester United has been tumultuous since his arrival in 2022. His future with the team faced uncertainty after a dismal display during a 4-0 defeat by Crystal Palace in May 2024, leading well-known pundit and former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher to suggest that the time had come for the Brazilian to consider retirement. Carragher bluntly advised him to leave the sport before it left him, referencing his diminished performance levels.
“It’s time for Casemiro to think about retirement before the game leaves him.” – Jamie Carragher
Just a few weeks later, in the FA Cup final against Manchester City, Casemiro found himself on the bench, ultimately opting out of play due to fitness concerns. Following United’s surprising 2-1 victory, he made a swift exit to enjoy a holiday with his family.
Challenges and Changes
Casemiro’s decision to remain with the club through the summer transfer window of 2024 surprised many, but further challenges awaited him. Early in the 2024-25 season, he was substituted at halftime during a match against Liverpool while the team trailed 2-0, making way for promising young player Toby Collyer, who was making his Premier League debut. This marked a dramatic shift in his standing, as he would only see action in two more league matches before Erik ten Hag, the manager at the time, was dismissed.
Ruben Amorim, who took over managerial duties, expressed uncertainty about Casemiro’s role. During the Brazilian’s lengthy absence from the lineup in December and January, Amorim acknowledged that while Casemiro possessed valuable game intelligence, he struggled to meet the Premier League’s intense demands. Despite appreciating Casemiro’s past success, he indicated that squad selection would hinge on current performance levels.
A Resurgence
Fast forward almost a year, and Casemiro’s resurgence has turned the narrative on its head. No longer a sidelined player, he has become a symbol of resilience for the whole United squad, demonstrating that hard work can alter fortunes. Amorim has pointed to Casemiro’s comeback as an inspiring example, particularly for younger players struggling for minutes.
Casemiro’s role this season has proven pivotal to Manchester United’s improved performance. Of the 20 goals allowed by United across all competitions, he was absent for 15. In critical matches against Brighton and Tottenham, his presence seemed to directly impact defensive solidity, as United had kept clean sheets until his substitutions. With younger players like Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte failing to keep pace, Amorim closely monitors Casemiro’s fitness, acknowledging his immense experience and influence on the team’s dynamics.
International Recognition and Future Uncertainty
Amid this resurgence, Casemiro has also been recalled to the Brazil national team, a decision facilitated by the appointment of Carlo Ancelotti as head coach, who has a longstanding relationship with the midfielder. The two previously won three Champions League titles together at Real Madrid. Ancelotti’s admiration for Casemiro was evident when he immediately included him in his latest national squad, recognizing his capabilities as a player who adds crucial attributes to the team.
While Casemiro seems back on track with his career, his long-term future with Manchester United remains uncertain. His contract is set to expire in June, and there had been indications he might leave on a free transfer, especially with United’s intent to reduce their wage bill post the departures of several high-earning players. However, Casemiro’s recent form has reignited discussions about extending his stay, albeit likely at a reduced salary.
As the Premier League season progresses, Casemiro’s focus remains on performing at a high level and contributing to United’s quest for success. With aspirations of participating in the upcoming World Cup, his immediate goal is to maintain his fitness and influence on the pitch, emphasizing the importance of stabilization in a demanding football environment.
