Surprising Player Performances Shaking Up Early NHL Season

2025-26 NHL Season Overview

As the 2025-26 NHL season unfolds, it has already revealed an array of unexpected developments. Both teams and players have shown surprising results, with some exceeding expectations while others struggle to find their footing. We take a look at ten standout performances that have caught the eye this season, as well as five players whose starts have been less than stellar.

Strong Starts

Carlsson’s Emergence

With stats showing 16 games played, 11 goals, and 15 assists, Leo Carlsson is proving to be a significant asset for the Anaheim Ducks. Selected second overall in 2023, Carlsson’s rookie year was marred by limited playtime, yet last year he started to shine with a respectable 20 goals and 25 assists in 76 games. Under the guidance of new coach Joel Quenneville, he’s now flourishing, helping the Ducks secure the top spot in the Pacific Division. This improvement is reflected in the team’s shot and scoring chances when Carlsson is on the ice.

Kiefer Sherwood’s Surprising Goal-Scoring

An unexpected sensation for the Vancouver Canucks, Kiefer Sherwood found the net 11 times in 18 appearances, building on his cult hero status among fans despite a humble previous high of 19 goals in a season. This unexpected scoring spree has fans humorously speculating whether he could sustain this scoring pace.

Marchand’s Leadership

Celebrated forward Brad Marchand has stepped up in the absence of key injuries for the Florida Panthers, tallying 11 goals and seven assists over 15 games. After a stellar playoff performance, he is playing a pivotal role in keeping the Panthers competitive as they await the return of their injured stars.

Rookies Making Headlines

Among the newcomers, Josh Doan has made an impact for the Buffalo Sabres with four goals and five assists. The son of NHL legend Shane Doan, he’s been getting more playing time, illustrating potential growth as he integrates into the team. Moreover, 18-year-old defenseman Schaefer has exceeded expectations, effectively transitioning into a key player for the Islanders, contributing 12 points in 16 games.