Manchester City’s Struggles Without Haaland: What’s Their Backup Plan?

Manchester City’s Goal-Scoring Dilemma

Manchester City is facing scrutiny regarding their strategy for situations where star striker Erling Haaland is unable to find the back of the net. In a recent match against Newcastle United, which ended in a 2-1 loss for City at St. James’ Park, Haaland failed to score, raising concerns about the team’s reliance on his goal-scoring abilities. This season, the Norwegian forward has tallied 14 goals in the Premier League, while his teammates have collectively scored only eight times, with no one managing to find the net more than once.

Concerns from Former Players

Former City defender Micah Richards voiced his concerns during a discussion on Sky Sports, emphasizing the team’s dependency on Haaland.

“They had chances, but Haaland missed them. The question is, who else will rise to the occasion?”

He pointed out that although players like Phil Foden and Jérémy Doku have performed well individually, they faltered when it mattered most in crucial moments.

Potential Risks and Team Dynamics

Richards raises a critical question: What will happen if Haaland sustains an injury or encounters a prolonged slump in form? While acknowledging Foden’s potential to step up, he cautioned that there needs to be a shift in mentality and execution amongst the team during pressing moments. He remarked,

“It’s not solely about individual performance; it’s about delivering in key moments. Newcastle capitalized while City didn’t seem as effective.”

Adding to the complexity for manager Pep Guardiola, Richards pointed out potential issues surrounding squad depth and player roles. He referenced Rayan Cherki‘s involvement as a concern, noting that although City had numerous scoring opportunities, the team lacked a solid midfield presence without Tijjani Reijnders and Rodri, both key figures against Liverpool in their previous match.

Challenges at St. James’ Park

Richards commented on the difficulties faced when playing at St. James’ Park, where opposing teams often bring a more physical midfield presence.

“City was caught between formations, aiming for a high press, yet lacking the necessary energy and pressing intensity they once had. Once that midfield line is breached, the pressure falls on the defense, which can result in less support for the back line,”

he explained.

Looking Ahead

With Haaland approaching the milestone of 100 Premier League goals—needing only 16 more goals in the remaining matches to beat Alan Shearer’s record for the fastest century—the stakes for City’s offense have never been higher. As they look ahead, it is clear that diversifying their scoring threats is critical to maintaining competitive momentum in the league.