Fans Weigh In on Hibernian’s Goalkeeping Situation
In a recent discussion regarding Hibernian’s goalkeeping situation, fans shared their diverse opinions on whether Jordan Smith should keep the number one spot for the upcoming season. Since joining the squad, Smith has shown promise, but whether he is the long-term solution remains a point of debate among supporters.
Mixed Opinions on Smith’s Future
Keith expressed skepticism, noting,
“While Smith has performed quite well, I wonder if he’s truly the solution we need. It’s vital to enhance our overall team, and the goalkeeper position is integral to that effort.”
On a more positive note, Billy argued in favor of Smith, stating,
“He has been exceptional since becoming part of the team. The game is a collective effort, and his contributions are invaluable; any new signing would have to accept being his backup, as he has solidified his place.”
Neil acknowledged Smith’s good performances but also pointed out areas for growth, remarking that he has occasionally made mistakes that led to goals.
“We should consider bringing in someone to genuinely compete for his position. It’s crucial to have that kind of healthy competition.”
Concerns about Depth and Competition
Donald echoed the sentiment that Smith has merited his position but questioned the absence of a capable understudy from the academy. Meanwhile, Alan suggested that Hibs should recall Kevin Dabrowski from Raith Rovers, who previously excelled in the Championship. He criticized Smith for being unsteady at times and lacking finesse with his feet.
David felt that while Smith should retain his role as the starting goalkeeper, there’s an urgent need for a high-quality challenger, especially with the demands of European competitions looming. He emphasized Smith’s positive impact since joining the first team despite acknowledging he is prone to errors.
Kieron highlighted particular concerns about Smith’s hesitance to come off his line, which has cost the team goals in the past. He expressed hope that Hibs might bring in an adept goalkeeper capable of addressing this issue. Additionally, it remains uncertain if the club will recruit another third-choice keeper or promote someone from the academy.
Conclusion
In sum, while Smith has garnered strong support from many fans, a considerable call for both competition and improvement resonates within the Hibs community as they prepare for next season.
