Assessing Defense Options for the Penguins Ahead of NHL Trade Deadline

Pittsburgh Penguins’ Upcoming Matches and Trade Considerations

After the Olympic break in 2026, the Pittsburgh Penguins will face five critical matches leading up to the NHL Trade Deadline, set for the 2025-26 season. Their current standings and performance over the past couple of months place them in a position where they could be active in the trade market, reminiscent of last year when they operated as a hybrid buy-sell team.

Current Player Landscape

While players like Jason Robertson and Robert Thomas capture the imagination of fans, such high-profile trades are likely more suited for the offseason rather than in the midst of a competitive season. Moreover, considering that the Dallas Stars are genuine contenders for the Stanley Cup, acquiring Robertson doesn’t seem feasible at this moment.

Currently, the forward lineup appears well-stocked, with promising talents such as Rutger McGroarty, Avery Hayes, and Ville Koivunen, all of whom are vying for playing time in the NHL but are held back by roster constraints.

Defensive Needs and Potential Trade Targets

On the other hand, the Penguins’ defensive unit may require bolstering. The injury to Kris Letang and Erik Karlsson‘s Olympic participation highlight the need for additional depth, not just for the current season but looking forward. General Manager Kyle Dubas has previously indicated a preference against acquiring aging rental players, steering the Penguins towards younger athletes with contracts extending beyond the current season.

Potential Trade Targets

  • Simon Benoit from the Toronto Maple Leafs: At 27 years old and under contract for $1.35 million per annum until the end of next season, Benoit is not known for his offensive contribution but has shown exemplary defensive skills. His performance metrics reveal he excels in limiting opposing scoring chances, making him a valuable addition as a bottom-pairing defenseman during playoff runs.
  • Zach Whitecloud from the Calgary Flames: Now 29 years old and earning $2.75 million annually for the next few seasons, he provides solid depth on defense. Although he lacks offensive flair, Whitecloud could enhance the Penguins’ defensive roster amid the Flames’ rebuilding efforts, providing they are willing to meet the trade demands.
  • Mario Ferraro with the San Jose Sharks: The 27-year-old remains an unrestricted free agent after this season, presenting a potential rental scenario. He has consistently outperformed his peers in suppressing scoring opportunities, offering a blend of defensive skill and some offensive upside.
  • Logan Stanley of the Winnipeg Jets: Notable for his significant physical stature, standing at 6-foot-7 and over 230 pounds, this season has marked a breakout year for him as he heads into free agency. While his capabilities on the market may lead to a high asking price, he remains a potential option for bolstering the Penguins’ defense.
  • Braden Schneider from the New York Rangers: At just 24, he’s still a restricted free agent after this season, but his development has been inconsistent. Acquiring him provides an opportunity to evaluate his fit, with the option to let him go if he does not meet expectations.

Conclusion

As the Penguins navigate these choices, careful consideration will shape their approach as the trade deadline approaches, seeking the right balance between immediate needs and long-term potential.