Analyzing the Knicks’ Remarkable Yet Flawed Season and Future Prospects

The Knicks’ Historic Playoff Run

The New York Knicks experienced a tumultuous yet historic playoff run this season, falling just short of the NBA Finals. Following a pivotal Game 5 defeat to the Boston Celtics, where they squandered a strong lead, the team regrouped in Tarrytown, New York, for an urgent player-only meeting facilitated by veteran P.J. Tucker, who was brought on to enhance team leadership and communication.

The Knicks were on the brink of history; a victory would have marked their first trip to the Eastern Conference Finals in 25 years, holding a 3-2 series lead.

Turning Point and Collapse

Recognizing a lack of seriousness in their previous game, the players rallied to refocus, propelling them to a stunning 38-point win over the defending champions in Game 6—an unprecedented victory margin in franchise playoff history. However, the momentum was short-lived. In their following series against the Indiana Pacers, the Knicks suffered an unexpected collapse, blowing a 14-point lead in the dying minutes of regulation and ultimately losing in overtime.

They concluded their playoff journey after six games against the Pacers, falling two wins shy of reaching the Finals, but still marked their best season in years.

Regular Season Highlights

The 2025 Knicks achieved a solid record of 51 wins in the regular season—their best since 2013—and overcame the Detroit Pistons in the first round with thrilling plays, including a remarkable moment from Jalen Brunson. Their storied journey included a stunning upset over the Celtics, showcasing the talent and resilience of a roster featuring stars like Brunson, Karl-Anthony Towns, and Mikal Bridges.

Yet, the team consistently faced challenges with communication and performance stability, prompting multiple player meetings aimed at addressing both on-court and interpersonal issues.

Inconsistencies and Future Considerations

Despite their notable successes, the Knicks grappled with inconsistency, exemplified by fluctuating performances between impressive victories against top-tier teams and puzzling losses against lesser competition. Among the myriad challenges was the reliance on heavy minutes for starters, as critiqued by some players, including Bridges, who questioned the coaching strategy during a press conference.

The Knicks’ roster underwent drastic changes last summer with strategic trades, aiming to create a dynamic starting five capable of contending with the league’s elite. Tommy Thibodeau, the head coach, navigated line-up adjustments throughout the season, hoping to optimize player performance, especially with the influx of Towns and Bridges. However, despite the talent, the synergy didn’t meet expectations, particularly during the playoffs where they faced criticism for failing to adapt under pressure.

Looking Ahead

As they evaluate their future, the Knicks must determine how to build upon this transformative season. With core players like OG Anunoby, Brunson, and Josh Hart secured for years to come, they hold promise for next season, especially as the Eastern Conference landscape shifts. Key decisions await, particularly regarding Bridges’ forthcoming contract, which highlights their upcoming offseason priorities and potential roster adjustments.

While the season concluded in disappointment, it also offered valuable lessons and opportunities for growth as the Knicks aim to establish consistency and capitalize on their collective potential in the years to come.