Al Bernstein Critiques Judges in Morrell vs. Khataev Bout
Hall of Fame sports commentator Al Bernstein has publicly criticized the judges responsible for the contentious outcome of the bout between David Morrell and Imam Khataev at The Ring III event, deeming the decision ‘inconceivable.’ Bernstein, who has established himself as a significant figure in boxing commentary over the past forty years, emphasized that after watching the fight twice in one evening, he arrived at what he branded ‘the only reasonable conclusion.’
“Khataev clearly won at least six rounds, likely seven. Considering the knockdown he scored in the fifth round, there is no way to legitimize scoring this fight in favor of David Morrell.”
Directly addressing the scoring controversy, he particularly criticized the three judges for their poor performance. Bernstein pointed out that John McKaie’s score of 96-93 in favor of Morrell, implying he awarded Morrell seven rounds, was indefensible. He also called out Allen Nace, who scored the fight 95-94 for Morrell, claiming that this too was untenable. Bernstein noted that even Tony Lundy, who had a score of 95-94 for Khataev, failed to reflect the fight’s reality by giving Khataev only five rounds.
Bernstein backed his judgment with a thorough examination of the fight, concluding that to score the match for Morrell, individuals must be either “biased or blind.” The fight statistics added to his claims, showing the total number of punches landed was equal at 171 for both fighters, yet Khataev significantly outperformed Morrell with 129 power punches against Morrell’s 97, alongside a notable lead in body punches.
Ongoing Debate and Future Implications
This judging debacle has stirred intense debate among fans and analysts, who continue to call for transparency and accountability in boxing scoring. As discussions unfold regarding the possibility of a rematch, World Boxing News will provide ongoing coverage of this developing story.
Phil Jay, an experienced boxing journalist with a 15-year track record in the sport, serves as Editor-in-Chief for World Boxing News and has reported extensively from ringside during major boxing events. Readers are encouraged to subscribe to the WBN newsletter for expert updates and insights in the boxing world.
