Introduction to Connor McDavid
Connor McDavid, who debuted in the NHL back in 2015, is celebrated for his remarkable speed and goal-scoring talent, firmly establishing himself as one of the league’s most outstanding athletes. Throughout his career with the Edmonton Oilers, he has garnered numerous accolades, including leading the league in points five times during his ten seasons.
Due to his stellar reputation, McDavid’s rookie cards have become highly coveted among collectors. In a testament to this, during the Oilers’ playoff run for the Stanley Cup in 2025, an extraordinary Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Rookie Patch Autograph card that incorporates a piece of his jersey sold for a staggering $305,000 at Heritage Auctions, marking a record for any McDavid card.
Affordable Options for Collecting McDavid Cards
If you’re keen to start your own McDavid card collection but seeking more affordable options, you’re in the right place.
Top Picks for McDavid Rookie Cards
-
2015 Upper Deck Young Guns #201
This card is the gold standard among modern NHL rookie cards, known for its high-quality imagery and limited production. As the go-to option for hockey card collectors, it’s frequently recommended for those eager to invest in McDavid memorabilia. Prices for PSA 9 graded examples hover around $1,000, while more pristine PSA 10 copies can exceed $2,500.
-
2015 Upper Deck Star Rookies #1
For newcomers to collecting, the Star Rookies box set is a cost-effective entry point. It does not have the traditional packaging seen in other sets but includes rare autograph parallels. While graded examples sell for around $100, raw versions can be secured for as little as $15-$30, making it a solid addition for budget-conscious collectors.
-
2015 Upper Deck Parkhurst #PR1
Dating back to the 1950s, Parkhurst cards have a well-established legacy in the hockey card industry. McDavid’s Parkhurst rookie card was included in Black Friday packs available at Walmart, with PSA 10 graded versions currently valued at approximately $250, while raw cards are available for $30-$60.
-
2015 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Marquee Rookies #M1
Esteemed for its vibrant refractors, the O-Pee-Chee brand has been integral since the 1930s. McDavid’s card in this set is limited and valued around $200 for PSA 10 examples. In March 2025, one of its limited Gold Seismic Refractor variants fetched over $10,000, showcasing its desirability.
-
2015 Upper Deck Artifacts #205
This card stands out due to its redemption aspect, allowing collectors to swap a redemption card for a limited McDavid rookie card. Selling for around $600 if graded as PSA 10, it reflects the growing interest in collectibles with unique histories.
For those willing to spend a bit more, special parallels and high-end rookie cards are also available:
- 2015 Upper Deck The Cup Rookie Patch Auto #197: Often fetching extraordinary prices, one particularly pristine card sold for over $200,000 in 2022.
- 2015 SP Authentic Future Watch Rookie Autograph #226: Known for its authenticity, selling PSA 10 versions can reach between $10,000-$15,000 due to their direct player signatures.
Collecting Memorabilia of Connor McDavid
Finally, for collectors who appreciate McDavid’s early career, the 2009 Quebec Pee-Wee Tournament #910 trading card showcases a young McDavid and is a charming piece of memorabilia selling around $50.
As you embark on this collecting journey, remember to enjoy the process of finding cards that resonate with you. Keep in mind the fluctuating values in this market, which can be influenced by various factors including player performance, collector demand, and economic conditions. With the right strategies and a bit of luck, you can start or enhance your collection of one of hockey’s greatest talents.
