2025 NHL Mock Draft: Wheeler, Pronman, and Bultman Assume General Manager Roles for a First-Round Selection

Mock Draft Overview

In an engaging exercise for the third consecutive year, Corey Pronman, Scott Wheeler, and Max Bultman reunited to simulate the role of general managers in the upcoming NHL draft, providing an intriguing insight into their choices for the first round. Unlike standard mock drafts which aim to predict actual outcomes, this collaborative mock draft allows each analyst to select players directly for each team based on their individual assessments, setting the stage for lively debate and discussion.

Selection Process

The selection order was randomly established, with Wheeler taking the lead, followed by Bultman in the second position, and Pronman rounding out the trio at third. Each writer presented their rationale behind selecting specific players, presenting a fascinating blend of strategy and opinion.

Player Selections

Wheeler highlighted defenseman Matthew Schaefer, referring to his exceptional skating ability and potential to develop into a franchise cornerstone. He acknowledges the allure of local prospect Michael Misa for teams like the Islanders, who are in search of a top-tier center.

Bultman countered Wheeler’s defense-first approach by selecting Misa for the San Jose Sharks, noting the promising firepower he would bring alongside other young talents in their lineup. He emphasized Misa’s potential as a dynamic second-line center while also keeping open the option for him to play as a winger if needed.

Pronman faced a critical decision early in his mock GM experience. He ultimately favored Brampton’s Porter Martone for the Atlanta team, appreciating Martone’s ability to contribute both offensively and defensively. He also expressed concerns about the team’s center situation, preferring Desnoyers but acknowledging the need for a first-line center to complement the team better.

Emerging Strategies

As teams approached the middle of the first round, confounding choices emerged. One writer proposed taking Anton Frondell, underscoring his dual-threat ability as a center, while another favored a more skill-rich choice in Hagens, emphasizing the importance of balancing size and talent in the team’s core. Particularly notable was the ongoing discussion about whether smaller players could drive success in crucial playoff moments.

Concluding Insights

The mock drafting continued through multiple rounds, with discussions involving various prospects and potential placement strategies. Writers considered the balance between filling immediate needs and best available talent, taking into account organizational depth and future competition for positions.

In conclusion, this interactive mock draft showcased not only the writers’ perspectives on individual players but also the complexities of drafting in the NHL, highlighting how teams must juggle immediate needs with long-term strategic vision. With a diverse array of prospects discussed, this collaborative effort sheds light on how enthusiasm for young talent can shape the future of the league’s franchises.